| Team | Record | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| 63Colorado College | 7-0 | +126 |
| 82Air Force | 6-1 | -44 |
| 89St John's | 5-2 | -32 |
| 105Brandeis | 6-1 | +47 |
| 128Wheaton | 5-2 | +73 |
| 140Knox | 5-2 | -43 |
| 168Kalamazoo | 2-5 | -58 |
| 183Cedarville | 3-4 | +28 |
| 189Oberlin | 4-3 | +99 |
| 194Indiana Wesleyan | 2-5 | -61 |
| 205Xavier | 3-4 | -24 |
| 206Valparaiso | 3-4 | +7 |
| 220Truman State | 2-5 | -41 |
| 225Olivet Nazarene | 2-5 | -27 |
| 247St Olaf | 1-6 | -18 |
| 338*Ohio Valley | 0-7 | 0 |