| Tournament | Opponent | Result | Effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| T-Town Throwdown XII | 1-4 | +7 | |
| 28Auburn | Loss 13-2 | ignored | |
| 97Alabama-Birmingham | Loss 12-7 | -1 | |
| 156Indiana | Loss 11-7 | -11 | |
| 110Tennessee-Chattanooga | Win 10-9 | ineligible | |
| 149Alabama-Huntsville | Win 14-13 | +21 | |
| 92Clemson | Loss 15-3 | -3 | |
| 110Tennessee-Chattanooga | Loss 11-6 | ineligible | |
| DIII Midwestern Invite 2016 | 4-3 | +73 | |
| 183Olivet Nazarene | Win 13-8 | +38 | |
| 149Alabama-Huntsville | Loss 12-8 | -11 | |
| 258Trine | Win 13-10 | +7 | |
| 56Indiana Wesleyan | Loss 10-4 | ignored | |
| 188Drake | Loss 12-10 | -8 | |
| 233Wooster | Win 9-8 | +2 | |
| 183Olivet Nazarene | Win 13-11 | +21 | |
| Music City Tune-Up 2016 | 3-4 | -93 | |
| 204Ball State | Loss 13-6 | -45 | |
| 293Belmont | Win 13-8 | +4 | |
| 154Vanderbilt | Loss 11-8 | -8 | |
| 65Valparaiso | Loss 13-6 | +3 | |
| 149Alabama-Huntsville | Loss 13-7 | -23 | |
| 331*Vanderbilt-B | Win 15-4 | ignored | |
| 283*Western Kentucky | Win 11-6 | +13 | |
| Ohio D-III College Men's CC | 0-0 | 0 | |
| 248Ohio Northern | Win 9-6 | postseason | |
| 233Wooster | Win 10-9 | postseason | |
| 80Franciscan | Loss 13-5 | postseason | |
| 112Oberlin | Loss 14-6 | postseason | |
| 262Ohio Wesleyan | Win 12-9 | postseason | |
| Ohio Valley D-III College Men's Regionals | 0-0 | 0 | |
| 225Kenyon | Loss 12-10 | postseason | |
| 112Oberlin | Loss 12-6 | postseason | |
| 215Cedarville | Win 12-11 | postseason | |
| 160Haverford | Loss 11-7 | postseason | |
| 80Franciscan | Loss 15-10 | postseason | |
| 233Wooster | Loss 12-9 | postseason | |