| Tournament | Opponent | Result | Effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Windy City Whammy 2016 | 4-1 | +39 | |
| 298Rose-Hulman | Win 13-5 | ignored | |
| 228Wisconsin-La Crosse | Win 11-8 | +20 | |
| 331*Illinois-C | Win 13-2 | ignored | |
| 246Northern Iowa | Win 13-5 | +35 | |
| 159Wisconsin-Whitewater | Loss 11-8 | -24 | |
| Last Call 2016 | 2-2 | +27 | |
| 119Illinois State | Loss 11-10 | +20 | |
| 73Loyola-Chicago | Loss 11-8 | +16 | |
| 247Southern Indiana | Win 13-10 | +7 | |
| 344*Illinois State-B | Win 13-5 | ineligible | |
| 344*Reaper Alum II | Loss 13-11 | ineligible | |
| 265Missouri State | Win 11-10 | -25 | |
| Huck Finn XX 2016 | 0-6 | -66 | |
| 47Notre Dame | Loss 13-3 | ignored | |
| 46LSU | Loss 10-3 | ignored | |
| 73Loyola-Chicago | Loss 9-6 | +11 | |
| 46LSU | Loss 15-6 | ignored | |
| 147St Louis | Loss 15-7 | -52 | |
| 90Washington University | Loss 15-9 | -9 | |
| Northern South Central D-III College Men's CC | 0-0 | 0 | |
| 244Tulsa | Win 13-4 | postseason | |
| 81Air Force | Loss 12-8 | postseason | |
| 176Colorado Mines | Loss 12-2 | postseason | |
| 303Hendrix | Win 13-3 | postseason | |
| 214Harding | Win 12-8 | postseason | |
| South Central D-III College Men's Regionals | 0-0 | 0 | |
| 109Rice | Loss 10-9 | postseason | |
| 176Colorado Mines | Win 10-8 | postseason | |
| 52John Brown | Loss 11-9 | postseason | |
| 87Colorado College | Loss 13-8 | postseason | |
| 81Air Force | Loss 13-9 | postseason | |
| 109Rice | Loss 13-10 | postseason | |