| Tournament | Opponent | Result | Effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Easterns Qualifier 2016 | 0-0 | 0 | |
| 223Mississippi | Win 11-9 | ineligible | |
| 50North Carolina State | Loss 13-9 | ineligible | |
| 137Tennessee | Win 13-6 | ineligible | |
| 106Tufts | Loss 11-7 | ineligible | |
| 18Ohio State | Loss 15-8 | ineligible | |
| 68*Delaware | Win 15-9 | ineligible | |
| 106Tufts | Win 15-9 | ineligible | |
| 58William & Mary | Win 9-7 | ineligible | |
| River City Tune Up 6 | 6-1 | -58 | |
| 199MIT | Win 13-5 | ignored | |
| 278Edinboro | Win 13-2 | ignored | |
| 286Luther-B | Win 13-2 | ignored | |
| 111South Carolina | Win 8-4 | +14 | |
| 112Oberlin | Loss 7-6 | -65 | |
| 199MIT | Win 13-1 | ignored | |
| 286Luther-B | Win 13-1 | ignored | |
| Huck Finn XX 2016 | 5-2 | +226 | |
| 147St Louis | Win 12-6 | -4 | |
| 118Mississippi State | Win 12-6 | +13 | |
| 54Northwestern | Win 12-5 | +51 | |
| 34Missouri | Win 9-5 | +65 | |
| 18Ohio State | Loss 15-10 | -42 | |
| 119Illinois State | Win 15-8 | +11 | |
| 25Cal Poly-SLO | Loss 12-9 | -41 | |
| West Penn D-I College Men's CC | 0-0 | 0 | |
| 263*Indiana | Win 13-2 | postseason | |
| 278Edinboro | Win 13-3 | postseason | |
| 6Pittsburgh | Loss 13-9 | postseason | |
| 139Shippensburg | Win 13-10 | postseason | |
| 200West Virginia | Win 13-5 | postseason | |
| 168Carnegie Mellon | Win 13-9 | postseason | |
| 6Pittsburgh | Loss 15-12 | postseason | |
| Ohio Valley D-I College Men's Regionals | 0-0 | 0 | |
| 134Temple | Win 15-8 | postseason | |
| 168Carnegie Mellon | Win 15-6 | postseason | |
| 49Ohio | Win 15-7 | postseason | |
| 103Lehigh | Win 14-7 | postseason | |
| 32Case Western Reserve | Loss 15-9 | postseason | |
| 6Pittsburgh | Loss 15-11 | postseason | |